When the World Tips Over: A Review of Family Shadows
When I heard that Jandy Nelson, the brilliant mind behind the heartwarming "I’ll Give You the Sun," was back with a new novel after nearly a decade, my heart skipped a beat. I dove into When the World Tips Over with a mix of excitement and trepidation, eager to see how this legendary author would explore the complex tapestry of family and generational trauma. Unfortunately, I emerged not only disheartened but bewildered by the chaotic dynamics presented in this 500+ page family saga.
Nelson’s exploration of family curses and blessings is indeed intriguing; she poses a question that resonates deeply: “If people bear the trauma of their ancestors, doesn’t it follow they also bear their rhapsodies?” While this theme had incredible potential, it felt buried under layers of unnecessary drama and frustrating character choices. The story centers on the Fall siblings, grappling with their lineage’s burdens and the arrival of an unexpected figure who could either illuminate or further complicate their struggles.
As I navigated the narrative, I was frustrated by the lack of care and empathy shown, especially from the parents towards their children. It left me yearning for some emotional warmth, but what I felt instead was a disconnection that grew stronger with each chapter. “What does that do to the forming psyche if your first experience of all-consuming boundaryless love is one of such profound loss?” It seemed as if the characters had been doomed before they even began their personal journeys.
Nelson’s writing style, unfortunately, felt inconsistent. The narrative shifted abruptly between perspectives, requiring a level of focus that was often undermined by disinterest. Moments of potential brilliance were marred by pacing issues and a rather perplexing character development. Dizzy was irritating, Wynton lacked agency, and Cassidy’s narcissistic tendencies often overshadowed the narrative, making it hard to empathize with anyone. Why do contemporary characters often seem to demand sympathy without earning it?
Despite these flaws, Nelson skillfully unveiled a compelling mystery that initially kept me engaged. Her pacing and the gradual revelation of secrets were definitely highlights, yet they couldn’t make up for the overwhelming chaos that ensued. I found myself frustrated not just with the characters’ choices but also with how these choices trivialized significant issues, including parental abandonment and extramarital affairs, making them feel disregarded in favor of dramatic storytelling.
The use of crass language by younger characters left me baffled. Reflecting on whether it was age-appropriate or even necessary, I felt disheartened by its pervasive presence in a narrative that could have benefitted from a more nuanced approach to such topics.
Ultimately, When the World Tips Over left me feeling like I had waded through a torrent of familial chaos, only to emerge more exhausted than enriched. While I acknowledge the effort and intention behind the story, it felt like a weighty exploration of darkness that undermined its potential for light.
This book may appeal to readers who appreciate intricate family dramas steeped in grief and dysfunction, but fair warning: you might find yourself yearning for more uplifting moments. I wish I could say it resonated with me, but honestly? It felt more like an infuriating slog through a familial curse than the rhapsody I had hoped for. If you’re looking for a gripping read that invites empathy and warmth, you might want to look elsewhere.
Discover more about When the World Tips Over on GoodReads >>