Some Like It Cold: A Sleeping Beauty with Ice-Cold Hearts
I’ve been a devoted fan of Elle McNicoll’s middle-grade novels, reveling in her ability to craft characters that feel like friends. When I learned she was venturing into the realm of young adult romance with Some Like It Cold, I was equal parts excited and apprehensive. Would her signature sparkle translate well into the world of teenage angst and romantic tension? Spoiler alert: the journey was more chilly than cozy, and I found myself walking away with a 2.5-star rating nestled in my heart.
Set in the dismal yet fantastical Lake Pristine, the narrative introduces us to Jasper, a neurodivergent young woman returning home for the festive season. Unfortunately, what should have been a celebratory time quickly devolves into an exploration of familial and societal cruelty. Lake Pristine is a far cry from the welcoming small-town life one might expect, fully embodying the title’s sinister implication. Rather than warmth, I was met with icy glares and backhanded remarks, leaving me baffled by the town’s collective bitterness.
Jasper’s return is marked by the sudden announcement of her sister’s New Year’s Eve wedding—a twist that serves as a catalyst for conflicts that feel both poignant and, at times, exhausting. As I turned the pages, the dialogue felt oddly formal, almost like each character was wary of revealing too much, even while being openly vicious towards one another. It left me yearning for more genuine connection, especially from Jasper, whose interactions often felt stilted.
Despite my reservations about the interpersonal conflicts, the slow-burn enemies-to-lovers romance between Jasper and her childhood rival Arthur Lancaster—affectionately dubbed “Grumble”—offered a refreshing ray of warmth amid the chilly surroundings. Their chemistry felt authentic, layered with banter and moments of genuine tenderness. Arthur, the brooding cinema manager with dreams of keeping his father’s legacy alive, emerged as the jewel of the story, a figure of empathy amidst the cold-hearted chaos of Lake Pristine.
One poignant quote struck me: “To be loved so well for exactly who you are, after being told you are unlovable: it was a beautiful, golden act of revolution.” This encapsulated much of Jasper’s struggle as she navigates her self-worth in a town that seems to take joy in tearing her down. It was a reminder of the importance of unconditional love and the powerful emotions tied to accepting oneself—a theme that resonated deeply with me.
While McNicoll’s thoughtful representation of neurodivergence is commendable, I wished the narrative had balanced it more gracefully with its other elements. The focus on Jasper’s neurodivergent experience sometimes veered into territory that felt almost burdensome, overshadowing other rich plot aspects. I found myself wishing for a more nuanced approach that didn’t require constant re-explanation of her struggles, which occasionally took away from the unfolding drama.
In conclusion, Some Like It Cold is a mixed bag of heartfelt moments and exhausting interactions, reflective of the complexities of familial dynamics and self-discovery. Fans of McNicoll might find it a departure from her previous works, but those who enjoy stories laden with family drama and a slow-burn romance may be drawn to Jasper and Arthur’s evolving relationship. While my heart felt heavy for most of this read, I appreciate how it pushed the boundaries of understanding and compassion, even amidst the harshness. For readers intrigued by intense emotional landscapes, this might just be a worth-it venture into the cold.
So, who might enjoy this book? If you’re ready to brave a wintery town of unkind characters, coupled with a beautiful exploration of love and belonging—Some Like It Cold might warm you up, albeit just a little.
[ad_2]