Book Review: Size 12 Is Not Fat by Meg Cabot
Growing up in the aughts, I was inevitably swept into the vibrant, whirlwind world of chick-lit. I distinctly remember snatching up Meg Cabot’s Size 12 Is Not Fat, captivated by the promise of laughter, love, and a sprinkle of mystery. It’s been quite the ride revisiting these stories as an adult, grappling with how they both shaped my teenage perceptions and now challenge them. This book, despite its title and cover that hint at an empowering narrative, unfolds into a reflection of cultural attitudes toward body image, and, like a gnawing chipmunk in my brain, it raises questions that are just as relevant today.
At the heart of Size 12 Is Not Fat is Heather Wells, a pop star turned dormitory resident advisor who, post-breakup and weight gain, is navigating a new life that’s decidedly less glamorous than her previous fame. Cabot paints Heather with humor, wit, and a dash of vulnerability as she deals with her job’s bizarre challenges (seriously, who knew "elevator surfing" was a thing?). But beneath the laugh-out-loud moments lies a deep-seated insecurity that resonates painfully, even today. While it’s meant to be comedic, the constant reminders of Heather’s size—she’s a size twelve, after all—invite us to contemplate real societal expectations about weight.
Heather’s voice is candid, often biting. It’s entertaining, yet I couldn’t help but feel a twinge of discomfort when she disparages those who are naturally slim, turning the narrative into somewhat of a toxic loop. I found it striking that she claims, “Size 12 Is NOT Fat,” while also being subjected to slights about her weight repeatedly throughout the story. It’s hard to ignore how such language molds perceptions, especially for readers like myself who once navigated their own body-related insecurities at that very size.
Cabot’s writing style is undoubtedly engaging; her pacing keeps you turning the pages, nestled in the rich, lively backdrop of New York City. The plot unfurls with mystery as Heather dives into an investigation surrounding a student’s untimely death, pushing back against the idea that young women are too “chill” to engage in risky behaviors. This commentary, while it made me chuckle, also struck me as a critique of the collective understanding of female behavior—a theme I found refreshing without being preachy.
The supporting cast brings a delightful depth to Heather’s journey. From her Dominican friend, Magda, to her charming love interest—a private detective with a soft spot for dogs—Cabot attempts to infuse diversity into the narrative. It’s a commendable effort that includes conversations on race and gender, sparking both joy and contemplation as I navigated through the characters’ interactions.
Ultimately, I walked away from Size 12 Is Not Fat feeling empowered yet aware. It’s a mixed bag of nostalgia—brought to life by Cabot’s knack for humor and drama—yet undeniably marred by some toxic undertones that echo through its pages. I’ll admit, I found the mystery aspects fun, and guess what? I’m here for a hot male detective with a heart of gold!
In conclusion, if you’re someone who enjoyed the era of early 2000s chick-lit but are now wrestling with its outdated narratives, Size 12 Is Not Fat might be a worthwhile read, albeit with some critical thought. It’s a rollercoaster ride of entertainment, perfect for a light read on a rainy day—but perhaps not the best choice for those seeking a wholesome message about body image. Still, who doesn’t love a nostalgic jaunt through the heart of a comic mystery? After all, sometimes it’s just nice to lose yourself in a world that feels like a slice of your past.
4 stars for fun, nostalgic entertainment—just tread carefully through the weighty issues!
Discover more about Size 12 Is Not Fat (Heather Wells, #1) on GoodReads >>
