Review of Jemima J by Jane Green: A Rollercoaster of Emotion and Perception
There are books that nudge you ever so gently into introspection, and then there are novels that grab you by the collar and give you a good shake. Jane Green’s Jemima J clearly falls into the latter category. When I picked it up, I was expecting a light-hearted romp through the ups and downs of weight, love, and self-image. What I didn’t prepare for was a narrative that would both resonate on a deeply personal level and simultaneously trigger an almost moral outrage within me.
At the heart of Jemima J is Jemima Jones, a woman who grapples with her weight and the societal pressures that come with it. Green portrays Jemima as an empathetic character, skillfully highlighting how her weight influences various aspects of her life, from job prospects to personal relationships. This part of the book felt well done and relatable, marking a rare moment of solace amidst the narrative chaos.
However, as Jemima’s story unfolds, we’re introduced to the "Stereotypical Romance Novel Hunk," Ben—who seems to have no flaws whatsoever—and an equally shallow Hollywood heartthrob, Brad. While Jemima’s interactions with Ben initially seemed captivating, her plunge into online dating with Brad quickly devolves into a narrative that left me feeling utterly frustrated. Green’s portrayal of characters, both high and low, often tips between sympathetic and thoroughly insufferable.
Perhaps my biggest issue with Jemima J lies in the portrayal of weight and attractiveness. Jemima’s transformation from "grossly overweight" to "gorgeous" is impactful—yet it also begs deep philosophical questions about self-worth and societal validation. Is it genuinely about love or simply a quest to conform to societal beauty standards? The introduction of characters like Jenny, Brad’s "Grossly Fat Assistant," did little to counter this narrative, as the protagonist’s dismissive attitude toward her reeked of patronization.
Moreover, Green’s omniscient narrator adds an unexpected layer of frustration. By the time I reached the melodramatic conclusion—where Jemima’s happily-ever-after feels more like a forced consolation than a celebratory end—I found myself yearning for a more nuanced exploration of the themes at play.
Although I had notable moments of connection—Jemima’s struggles made me think about the complexities of self-acceptance—these were often drowned out by my irritation with the characters and their antics. Moments that could have been profound were often dulled by the superficiality that seemed to dominate the plot.
So, who might enjoy Jemima J? Readers looking for a provocative exploration of beauty, romance, and the societal expectations that imprison us may find value in its pages. However, be prepared for an emotional rollercoaster—one that might leave you feeling conflicted but still reflective about the broader implications of the narrative. For my part, Jemima J has left me pondering: Can we really separate self-worth from society’s perception of beauty, or are we merely caught in a cycle of conforming and rebelling?
Ultimately, Jane Green’s Jemima J is more than just a story—it’s a mirror reflecting the often uncomfortable realities of weight, love, and personal identity, shaking us out of our complacency, even when it’s infuriating to read.
Discover more about Jemima J on GoodReads >>
