Good in Bed: A Reflection on Identity, Love, and the Unwanted Drama
Curled up on my couch with a pile of chick-lit books, I stumbled upon Good in Bed by Jennifer Weiner. The title alone sparked my curiosity, and I thought, "Finally, something to scratch that itch for good old-fashioned fun!" However, what I hoped would be a delightful romp turned out to be a tangled exploration of identity and self-acceptance, leaving me a bit disappointed. While I usually crave a fluffy romance with charming banter and a happy ending, this book sort of redefined my expectations in an unexpectedly heavy way.
At the heart of the novel is Cannie Shapiro, a 5’10" woman navigating her life as a size 16. It’s refreshing to see a plus-size protagonist, yet I found myself irked by how much of her narrative revolves around her grievances about being "big." While it’s valid to address body image issues, it’s disheartening when Cannie spends more time lamenting her figure than embracing her strengths. Weiner’s intent might be to normalize plus-size romance, but it felt like there was an imbalance in focus—too many moments of self-pity left me wanting more empowerment instead.
As the plot unfolds, Cannie’s messy relationship with her ex, Bruce Guberman, steals a considerable amount of the spotlight. Bruce is the quintessential pot-smoking slacker, whose vicious column about their romance adds layers of drama I honestly didn’t sign up for. I particularly cringed when I began to find some merit in Bruce’s jaded assessments of Cannie’s character. Watching their relationship play out felt less like engaging with a romance and more like observing a soap opera. Unfortunately, the new love interest, Peter, is overshadowed and underdeveloped, a nice guy with potential that sadly gets lost among the chaos.
As for the writing itself, Weiner’s prose is certainly captivating, managing to pull me into Cannie’s world. Yet, the pacing felt uneven; one moment you’re breezing through her experiences, and the next, you’re drowning in a complex web of characters and subplots that feel more akin to women’s fiction than the charming chick-lit I was hoping for. With 400 pages at her disposal, it seemed like Weiner tried to pack in every conceivable conflict, which ultimately diluted the core storyline.
Moments of levity pop up, such as Cannie’s celebrity best friend or her comedic yet absurd family dynamics, but they get lost amid the gravitas of personal struggles, like postpartum depression, that are only scratched at without proper diagnosis or resolution. While the drama reaches a peak when Cannie experiences a premature birth—thanks to Bruce’s new girlfriend pushing her—it felt like a plot twist simply for shock value.
All in all, Good in Bed offers a unique lens on relationships, self-acceptance, and the trials of modern womanhood. However, the sweet escapism that chick-lit often provides gets bogged down in too many heavy themes that don’t quite weave together cohesively.
This book might resonate with readers looking for an introspective journey of self-discovery, those who appreciate a nuanced take on body image, or fans of Weiner’s work. If you’re searching for an uncomplicated romance, however, this probably isn’t the book for you.
In the end, my reading experience left me with a few lessons learned about expectations versus reality. Sometimes, in the midst of searching for comfort in fiction, we find ourselves navigating a maze of emotional depth that we didn’t quite anticipate. And while Good in Bed may not have filled my desire for a cotton-candy romance, it certainly made me think—a quality I sometimes overlook in my quest for light-hearted reads.
Discover more about Good in Bed (Cannie Shapiro, #1) on GoodReads >>
