A Heartwarming Adventure of Second Chances in Finders Keepers

You know those stories that wrap around your heart like a cozy blanket? Finders Keepers by Sarah Adler is one of those treasures that had me hooked from the first page. As someone who cherishes quaint small-town romances with a sprinkle of magic, I couldn’t resist diving into this delightful read. With childhood sweethearts, a treasure hunt, and the charm of a tight-knit community, Adler presents a captivating narrative that’s hard to put down.

The journey begins when Nina Hunnicutt, our protagonist, returns to Catochin, Maryland, nursing her wounds after losing her job and breaking up with a long-term boyfriend. Immediately, I felt for her as she stumbled back into her childhood town, feeling like her dreams had crumbled. This element of vulnerability resonates deeply; everyone knows what it feels like to face setbacks and long for the safe embrace of home. But homecoming becomes a rollercoaster when she discovers that her childhood sweetheart, Quentin Bell, now lives next door. Quentin, who ghosted Nina during their teen years, adds a delicious twist to the narrative.

Quentin’s character absolutely shines in this tale. With his charming sarcasm and flair for pranks, he quickly stole the show for me. It’s brilliantly portrayed how he reintegrates into Nina’s life, slipping seamlessly into her family’s home. I loved how Adler crafted their dynamic—Quentin isn’t just a snarky neighbor; he’s a reminder of the past Nina thought she’d left behind. Their chemistry is palpable, and their banter is sharp, which added a fun layer to the narrative. Particularly, when he proposes they finish the treasure hunt they began at fifteen, I couldn’t help but feel the nostalgia and excitement of rekindling lost adventures.

One aspect that stood out is how Adler captures the complexities of emotions. Nina’s internal monologues, while occasionally frustrating due to her self-doubts, lend authenticity to her character. It’s a reminder that life is rarely straightforward, and grappling with feelings is part of the process. I appreciated that even during her hesitations, her fierce determination to carve a new path shone through, making her journey relatable and inspiring.

The pacing felt just right, guiding me through summer days filled with treasure hunts and tender moments, allowing the characters to breathe and grow. Adler’s prose is warm and inviting, making me feel right at home in Catochin. Plus, the whimsical idea of a treasure hunt coupled with the vibrant backdrop of a small town adds a delightful touch of magic.

As Nina and Quentin rediscover their connection, the narrative invites readers to explore themes of reconciliation and the countless ways one can find happiness. It’s a celebration of second chances—whether in love, friendships, or life choices—reminding us that sometimes, the past has a way of leading us to exactly where we need to be.

In essence, Finders Keepers is the perfect read for romance lovers looking for a story layered with depth, humor, and nostalgia. It will undoubtedly leave readers with smiles on their faces and warmth in their hearts. If you’re in search of a heartwarming adventure that inspires hope and second chances, I wholeheartedly recommend getting lost in this charming tale. Thank you to NetGalley and Berkley Publishing for the opportunity to dive into this delightful world—I’ll certainly carry its sweet echoes with me long after the last page.

Discover more about Finders Keepers on GoodReads >>

Find More Great Books

We have written lots of reviews of our favorite books. Find them on our review page!